On this page
MVHR vs PIV comes down to how airtight your house is. PIV is the low-cost fix for a leaky, damp existing home. MVHR suits an airtight home and only performs when it is designed and commissioned properly. A dMEV fan is the cheap option when the damp is in one bathroom or kitchen. So before you choose, find out how airtight the house is: an air test is best, and the age and state of the building is the fallback.
One point most guides miss: Approved Document F (2021), the ventilation guidance for England, lists MVHR and continuous extract for dwellings and does not mention PIV at all.
Last checked 26 October 2026, against Approved Documents F and L on GOV.UK, the Ofgem price cap page, one Screwfix listing and the Energy Saving Trust ventilation pages. We have not tested any ventilation unit, and the installer prices below are the installers' own estimates.
MVHR vs PIV vs dMEV at a glance
PIV is positive input ventilation. A loft unit pushes filtered loft air into the house at ceiling level. A dMEV fan is a decentralised mechanical extract fan that runs continuously at low speed in a wet room. MVHR is mechanical ventilation with heat recovery: ducted supply and extract through a heat exchanger.
The comparison table
| PIV | dMEV and central MEV | MVHR | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | Loft unit pushes filtered air in; damp air leaves through gaps | Continuous low-speed extract; air enters through trickle vents | Ducted supply and extract through a heat exchanger |
| Best for | Leaky, damp existing home | A bathroom or kitchen problem | Airtight home, new build or deep retrofit |
| Airtightness it suits | Leakier homes | Any (Approved Document F covers all dwellings) | Highly airtight homes |
| Typical installed cost | £500 to £1,500 (installer estimate) | £1,000 to £2,500 (installer estimate, MEV) | £4,000 to £8,000 (installer estimate); £3,000 to over £10,000 (CSE) |
| Running cost a year | Under £10, from £70 with heater (EnviroVent) | From under £20 (EnviroVent) | About £40 in a flat, £59 in a house (EnviroVent) |
| Heat recovery | None | None | 80% to 90% on paper (CSE); 73% minimum (Approved Document L) |
| Approved Document F | Not covered | Listed (continuous extract) | Listed |
| Maintenance | Filters in the loft unit | Cleaning, fan checks | Filters every 6 to 12 months; service from about £150 (Homebuilding) |
| Summer behaviour | Brings in loft air, which can be warm | Extract only | Bypass avoids adding heat; it does not cool |
| Retrofit difficulty | Low | Low to moderate | High: ducting and unit need space (CSE) |
The first installed-cost range for each system comes from one Sussex installer's guide of 8 February 2026, which cites no studies. CSE is the Centre for Sustainable Energy, page reviewed July 2026. Running costs are EnviroVent's, a manufacturer that sells PIV, from a page dated 1 January 2025. Heat recovery figures are unit efficiencies, not whole-house results, and we found no independent like-for-like price survey for the three systems. The 73% minimum appears in both the 2021 and 2026 editions of Approved Document L.
Choose PIV, dMEV or MVHR if
Choose PIV if the house is leaky, has condensation, has a usable loft, and you want the cheapest whole-house measure.
Choose dMEV if the damp is in a bathroom or kitchen and the rest of the house is fine.
Choose MVHR if the house is highly airtight or being made so, you can fit ducting, and you will pay for design and commissioning.
How each system works
PIV: filtered loft air pushed in at ceiling level
Nuaire's Drimaster-Eco data sheet describes the arrangement. The unit sits in the loft, draws air through filters and inputs it into the property at ceiling level. The house is gently pressurised, and damp air leaves through whatever gaps the building has.
This explains two limits. Loft air is unheated and PIV has no heat exchanger, so it recovers nothing. And it relies on leakage to let air out, which is why airtightness matters so much. Nuaire's heated version adds a built-in 400 W heater, and the data sheet says the unit goes to standby if the loft becomes excessively hot. Our PIV unit guide covers the hardware in more detail.
dMEV and MEV: extract only
A dMEV fan replaces an intermittent bathroom or kitchen fan with one that runs all the time at low speed. The 2026 edition of Approved Document L caps its specific fan power at 0.3 W per litre per second, the lowest cap in its table. Central MEV is one fan with ducts to several rooms. Fresh air arrives through trickle vents in both cases.
On mev vs mvhr, the principle is shared: both extract stale air continuously. MVHR adds a supply side and a heat exchanger, so incoming air is pre-warmed by outgoing air. That is also why MVHR cannot share a house with trickle vents, covered below.
MVHR: balanced supply and extract with a heat exchanger
MVHR uses ducting throughout the house, with the unit in a loft or cupboard. Approved Document L sets a minimum heat recovery efficiency of 73% for supply-and-extract units, plus a summer bypass and a variable speed controller. Our guide to what MVHR is explains the unit in full.
A heat pump is heating, not ventilation, and replaces none of these three. See our air-to-air heat pump guide if that is your question.
PIV vs MVHR: which is better for your home?
Neither wins in general. It depends on how much air your house leaks.
Start with airtightness
Approved Document F defines "highly airtight" as a design air permeability below 5 m3/(h.m2) at 50Pa, or an as-built figure below 3. For context, the 2026 Approved Document L sets 8.0 as the maximum for new dwellings. Homebuilding, an editorial source, says MVHR starts to work at 5, with bigger heating savings at 3.
One Sussex installer's guide says PIV works well at 8 to 10 and cannot work effectively at 3 to 5. That is a rule of thumb with no study cited, but it fits the mechanism: a pressurised house needs somewhere for air to go.
Only an air test tells you which side you are on. Without one, the age and condition of the house is a rough guide.
A rule for each type of home
Victorian or 1930s solid-wall terrace. Often leaky. Start with dMEV in the wet rooms or a PIV unit. MVHR is hard to justify here unless the house is being sealed as part of a deep retrofit.
1990s semi. Middle ground. A dMEV fan or PIV is the sensible first step. MVHR is rarely justified unless the house has been made much tighter.
Home after a big extension or full retrofit. Get an air test. MVHR becomes possible if the ducting fits, but the Centre for Sustainable Energy says retrofit is difficult because of the space ducts and the unit need.
Flat. There is usually no loft, so PIV is usually out. dMEV fans are the practical option, and MVHR depends on ceiling void space. Nuaire's MRXBOX95 MVHR sheet warns that limited ceiling voids in modern apartments lead to higher system resistance and running speeds.
New build. MVHR is one route to a compliant design, not a requirement. Do not read any guidance as saying Part L demands it.
If you are replacing windows
Approved Document F, paragraph 3.15, says new windows are likely to increase airtightness, and that without MVHR this may reduce beneficial ventilation. The Energy Saving Trust adds that a home with no vents or mechanical ventilation "may already be too airtight". It also says to keep trickle vents open all the time, and that trying to plug every gap may lead to poor air quality.
Sealing a leaky house is the step that makes PIV less effective and MVHR more worthwhile. Plan the ventilation before the draught-proofing, not after.
What the Building Regulations say
General information for England, not legal advice. Check with your local authority building control.
PIV is not covered by Approved Document F
Table 1.6 of the 2021 edition lists natural ventilation, continuous mechanical extract and MVHR. A text search of the 2021 and 2026 editions finds no mention of PIV. The table's note says that for situations outside its scope, expert advice should be sought.
That is not a ban, and it is not a finding that PIV does not work. It means the guidance gives you no design route for it, so the person selling you a PIV unit is working outside the document.
MVHR and trickle vents do not mix
Paragraph 1.72 says background ventilators should not be installed with MVHR, to avoid unintended air pathways. The 2026 edition keeps it. When MVHR is fitted to an existing dwelling, paragraph 3.11c says the existing vents should be covered or sealed shut.
Mechanical systems must be commissioned by an approved procedure, and a commissioning notice must be given to the building control body (2021 edition, paragraphs 1.83 and 4.1). Air flow rates in new dwellings must be measured (4.2). Flexible ducting is for final connections only, with a maximum length of 1.5 m (1.77).
The 2026 editions start on 24 March 2027
The 2026 Approved Documents F and L take effect on 24 March 2027 in England. The 2021 documents apply until then. The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government circular of 24 March 2026 gives the same coming-into-force date for the amendment regulations. We found no wording in either 2026 document that makes MVHR mandatory. Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own rules.
What each system costs
Buying and installing
Screwfix listed the Vent-Axia Pure Air Home PIV at £339.98 including VAT, and the heated version at £349.99, when we read it on 26 October 2026. Treat them as price anchors, not a ranking.
For MVHR, BPC Ventilation, a retailer, lists do-it-yourself kits at £2,304.16 for a BSK Notus 12 room kit (up to 225 m2) and £3,114.98 for a Vent-Axia 14 room kit aimed at a four-bedroom home, both including VAT. Its page excludes the electrician, which it budgets at £200 to £400, and says nothing about who commissions the system.
For a professional job, the Centre for Sustainable Energy says MVHR systems start from around £3,000 but could cost well over £10,000. One Sussex installer's own guide estimates installed prices of £500 to £1,500 for PIV, £1,000 to £2,500 for MEV and £4,000 to £8,000 for MVHR. Under £2,500 buys an MVHR kit, not a commissioned system. Our MVHR cost guide breaks the figures down.
Running costs
EnviroVent, a manufacturer, puts PIV at under £10 a year and from £70 with a heater, MEV from under £20, and MVHR at about £40 in a flat and £59 in a house, on a page dated 1 January 2025.
Our own arithmetic starts from Nuaire's data sheet, which gives a PIV fan power range of 1.6 W minimum to 17 W maximum. At the Ofgem price cap of 26.32p per kWh (1 October to 31 December 2026), 17 W running all year is about 149 kWh, or £39. At 1.6 W it is about 14 kWh, or £3.70.
The range is wide because the top end covers boost when the loft is warm, and a heater is extra. The cap changes each quarter. These are sums from a data sheet, not measured bills.
Filters, servicing and the real total
Homebuilding puts MVHR filters at about £20 a pair up to £120, changed every 6 to 12 months, with a service from about £150. PIV units also have filters. We found no sourced price for them.
A fair total adds purchase, installation, electrician, design, commissioning, electricity, filters and servicing. No source we found prices all of them like for like, so we give no single total.
Will it stop condensation and mould?
Sometimes. The field evidence is stronger for MVHR than for PIV, and no source we read says any of the three eliminates mould.
MVHR: good systems work, many are not good
Gupta and colleagues at Oxford Brookes reviewed 54 UK low-energy homes. They concluded that the rationale for MVHR is "borne out", with better CO2 levels and lower energy use. They also reported a "prevalence of sub-optimal systems", and found that some systems were chosen to meet the Code for Sustainable Homes without much understanding of the airtightness or maintenance they need. The paper's first page shows no year, so we give none.
Kapsali and Gupta studied six dwellings in three social housing schemes, a small sample. Energy use was three times the design figure, at a measured air permeability of 6 against a design target of 3. They blamed missing commissioning and users not understanding the controls.
The NHBC Foundation report NF52 (BRE authors, August 2013) covered ten homes near Slough. It says nine of the MVHR fan units were recommissioned after about a year, and that installers should be trained and experienced. Design, installation and commissioning decide the result.
PIV: thin and dated evidence
The substantial UK study we found is from April 2000, in Building Services journal. It was co-written by an employee of a Nuaire subsidiary, so it is dated and part-industry. In an unoccupied test house at BRE, relative humidity fell by around 7 to 10%. In 16 occupied homes, input ventilation was "not consistently effective". It worked in the most humid houses and did relatively little in the drier ones. The authors also said a low energy PIV system will not directly save energy.
We found no independent UK study measuring any heating penalty from PIV. The point that it brings in unheated loft air and recovers no heat is a mechanism, not a measurement.
Moisture has other causes
Cold surfaces, moisture sources and weak extraction all matter. Closed trickle vents are one cause, and the Energy Saving Trust says to keep them open all the time in a home without continuous mechanical supply and extract.
You may have read that...
These claims come up in Facebook and Reddit threads. They are opinions, so here is what the sources say.
Cost and savings claims
"MVHR is the best use of money." No primary source we found ranks it. The evidence points to MVHR being strongest in airtight homes and weak in leaky ones. Homebuilding puts the heating saving at under 5% at 5 m3/h/m2 and up to 20% at 3, though it cites no source for that.
"A DIY whole-house MVHR for a 4-bed costs under £2,500." That buys hardware at the cheap end, from the retail kit prices above. A commissioning notice is still required, and the electrician is extra.
Vents and heat recovery
"MVHR recovers 90% or more." That is the best case. A Nuaire unit's SAP Appendix Q table shows heat exchange efficiency from 91% falling to 85% as the duct system grows, while the marketing line on the same sheet says up to 95%. The Centre for Sustainable Energy says typically 80% to 90%. The Approved Document L minimum is 73%. Duct losses and poor balancing cut the figure further.
"With MVHR no trickle vents are needed." Correct, and more than that: Approved Document F says they should not be fitted, and existing ones should be sealed. The catch is that nothing replaces them if the system is not working. Gupta found homes relying on window opening where there was no background provision.
Air quality and cooling claims
"Mould, pollen and CO2 are completely eliminated." Overstated. Gupta found CO2 better in MVHR homes, but also sub-optimal systems. Filters reduce pollen only if they are changed.
"MVHR spreads the air conditioning's cold air in summer." Wrong as stated. VENTI, a manufacturer, says MVHR "cannot actively cool indoor spaces" because it has no refrigeration cycle. Zehnder says the aim of a summer bypass is to avoid worsening hot weather, and that bypass technology is not the same on every unit. Our guide to MVHR with air conditioning covers how the two are paired.
Find ventilation installers in Brighton and Hove
An F gas certificate shows a company can handle refrigerant. It says nothing about ventilation skill, and we have verified no ventilation qualification for any installer.
On 26 October 2026 we found two listed installers whose own pages mention both MVHR and PIV. Ernest Air Cooling in Shoreham-by-Sea says it specialises in professional MVHR systems across Sussex, and that PIV units can be installed in half a day because they need minimal ducting. Cen Air Solutions in Worthing lists MVHR and PIV ventilation among its services, in its own words about air quality and condensation. Both are the installers' claims. Ernest's own pages give typical installed prices of £850 to £1,500 for PIV and £7,999 to £12,000 for MVHR; Cen Air publishes no ventilation prices.
If you are in Brighton and Hove, our MVHR installer page shows which firms we found that mention MVHR or PIV, and what we could not confirm. The wider Brighton and Hove installer list is there if you want it. Treat both as a way to check, not a way to buy.
Whoever you ask, request three things in writing: the airtightness assumption behind the design, the commissioning certificate, and an itemised quote covering design, ducting, electrics and commissioning.
Questions
What is the difference between PIV and MVHR?
What are the downsides of a PIV unit?
Is a PIV unit worth it?
Do I need trickle vents with MVHR?
Can MVHR cool a house?
What is a dMEV fan?
Can I fit MVHR myself?
Sources
- Approved Document F, Volume 1: Dwellings, 2021 edition, England, GOV.UK (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Approved Document F, Volume 1: Dwellings, 2026 edition, GOV.UK (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings, 2026 edition, GOV.UK (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Approved Document L, Volume 1: Dwellings, 2021 edition incorporating 2023 amendments, GOV.UK (read 26 Oct 2026)
- MHCLG Circular, 24 March 2026, on S.I. 2026/335 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Energy Saving Trust, How to improve your home's ventilation (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Energy Saving Trust, Draught proofing (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Ofgem, Changes to the energy price cap between 1 October and 31 December 2026 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Gupta et al., Characterising the actual performance of domestic mechanical ventilation and heat recovery systems, Oxford Brookes (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Kapsali and Gupta, Low/zero energy social housing in UK, ECEEE Summer Study 2015 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- NHBC Foundation NF52, Assessment of MVHR systems and air quality in zero carbon homes, August 2013 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Stephen and Bradley, Positive input ventilation, Building Services, April 2000 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Nuaire, Drimaster-Eco PIV data sheet (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Nuaire, Positive input ventilation product page (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Nuaire, MRXBOX95 SAP Appendix Q catalogue sheet (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Screwfix, Vent-Axia Pure Air Home PIV (read 26 Oct 2026)
- BPC Ventilation, MVHR DIY kits guide 2026 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Zehnder UK, Summer bypass (read 26 Oct 2026)
- VENTI Group, Why can't MVHR be used for cooling? (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Centre for Sustainable Energy, Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Homebuilding, MVHR system cost (read 26 Oct 2026)
- EnviroVent, What is the difference between PIV and MEV (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Ernest Air Cooling, MVHR vs MEV vs PIV ventilation guide, 8 February 2026 (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Ernest Air Cooling, Ventilation (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Ernest Air Cooling, Heat recovery systems (read 26 Oct 2026)
- Cen Air Solutions, About us (read 26 Oct 2026)
Written and checked by Alex Christou. Found a mistake? Tell us; our corrections policy explains what happens next.



